ASPPH logo


Member Research & Reports

Member Research & Reports

Columbia and CUNY Professor Reports PTSD Raises Heart and Stroke Risk in World Trade Center Cleanup Crews

Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) may increase the long-term risk for stroke and heart attack in blue-collar clean-up crews who worked in the aftermath of The World Trade Center plane attack on September 11, 2001, according to new research by Dr. Alfredo Morabia, study senior author and professor of epidemiology at Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health and City University of New York. This is the first report from World Trade Center-Heart, a study investigating the association between the September 11 attack and cardiovascular outcomes among blue-collar workers involved in debris clearance. The findings are published online in  Circulation: Cardiovascular Quality and Outcomes, a journal of the American Heart Association.

“Even though there is evidence PTSD is not considered as a risk factor for cardiovascular disease, this study provides for the first time the evidence that PTSD is of the same magnitude for stroke and heart attack in men and women,” said Dr. Morabia.

PTSD is a psychological condition hallmarked by re-experiencing traumatic episodes, avoidance of triggers, hyperarousal and negative mood.

The World Trade Center-Heart study includes 6,841 non-firefighter workers and untrained volunteers (82.8 percent men, average age 51) — including staff from the medical examiner’s office who processed human remains and the Port-Authority Trans-Hudson Corporation and others who were engaged in the cleanup, recovery, service restoration and other tasks in the months following the attack.

[Photo: Dr. Alfredo Morabia]

Dr. Morabia and colleagues found that prevalence of PTSD was about 20 percent among men and 26 percent among women — at least twice that of the general population. Incidence of heart attack or stroke was 2.35 times higher for those with PTSD.

The researchers collected baseline mental health; blood pressure, cholesterol, whether participants began working on or after September 11, 2001; the proximity of their location to the site; whether they worked directly within the dust cloud, and whether they wore a protective mask.

While recognized as risk factors commonly associated with heart disease; blood cholesterol, blood pressure and body mass were not associated with heart attack or stroke in the subjects followed. Similarly, exposure to the dust was not independently associated with heart attack and stroke in this group.

“A major strength of our study is that it examined the impact of PTSD on heart disease in people 11 to 15 years after the occurrence of a major traumatic event as they entered the age group at which heart disease risk and events rise dramatically and provided four years’ worth of data on those subjects,” noted Dr. Morabia.

Despite the large sample size, the study may not provide an accurate cross-sectional representation for the approximately 90,000 first-responders who helped following the World Trade Center attack.

According to Dr. Morabia, the study also suggests that untrained first responders who engage in activities surrounding the aftermath of disasters are more likely to struggle with psychological challenges following their work than first responders who have received training.

“PTSD’s association with heart attack and stroke should be taken into consideration when untrained first responders are sent to respond to catastrophes of different types,” Dr. Morabia said. “Heart attack and stroke should be considered a related disease in World Trade Center first responders and it should be incorporated along with their benefits and care.”

The study was supported by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention/National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (grants 939ZLZB 2526 2011 75-11-0946 and 5U01OH010722-02).

Co-authors are Dr. Molly Remch and Ms. Zoey Laskaris, City University of New York; Dr. Janine Flory, Mount Sinai School of Medicine; and Ms. Consuelo Mora-McLaughlin, Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health.